Almost twenty years after ordering troops into Afghanistan, former President George W. Bush criticized President Joe Biden’s order to withdraw remaining personnel as endangering women, girls and those who’d supported the US and the Afghan central government.

Bush during an interview with German broadcaster Deutsche Welle warned that the consequences of withdrawing US and NATO troops from Afghanistan will be “unbelievably bad.”

“I’m afraid Afghan women and girls are going to suffer unspeakable harm,” Bush said, characterizing the pullout as a mistake without saying how he would quell the violence or when US troops should leave the longest war in its history.

The former president, who has largely refrained from making political remarks since leaving office, also expressed concern about Afghans who worked as translators or offered other support to foreign troops. “They’re just going to be left behind to be slaughtered by these very brutal people, and it breaks my heart,” Bush said.

Bush said he believed German Chancellor Angela Merkel “feels the same way.”

The war in Afghanistan, part of the broader “war on terror,” began under Bush. The US invaded Afghanistan in October 2001, not long after the 9/11 terror attacks that were carried out by extremists, mostly from Saudi Arabia, acting on the orders of al Qaeda leaders like Osama bin Laden thought to be based in Afghanistan. Roughly two decades later, the US is ending its military operations but the war on terror rages on.

The “global war on terror” that was launched by the Bush administration has killed over 800,000 people in direct war violence and led to the displacement of at least 37 million, according to a report from Brown University’s Costs of War project. The federal government also places the cost of the war on terror at over $6.4 trillion.

The war on terror remains among the most controversial aspects of Bush’s legacy, and scholars have widely characterized it as a major failure that damaged US credibility around the world.

Biden continues to defend the Afghanistan withdrawal as the Taliban makes gains

The human and economic cost of the conflict is a large part of the reason Biden, who as a senator voted in favor of the laws that paved the way for war on terror, has moved to end US involvement in Afghanistan.

Proponents of the withdrawal say it’s long overdue, and that the US has already lost too many lives and resources in the country. Opponents of the pullout say it’s too hasty and will effectively hand the country to militants on a silver platter. The Taliban recently said it’s taken over 85% of the country’s territory, though it’s difficult to verify this. According to The Foundation for Defense of Democracies, the Taliban currently controls 195 of the country’s 407 districts and is contesting another 129.

There are serious concerns about the ability of the Afghan military to maintain control of the country and prevent the Taliban from taking over. Almost as soon as US troops in early July departed from Bagram, the largest air base in the country, it was ransacked by looters. Control of the airbase was transferred over to the Afghan military, but local officials claimed the US did not coordinate with them and left in the dead of the night.

Earlier this week, CNN released video footage of 22 Afghan commandos being executed by the Taliban as they attempted to surrender. Responding to this report, GOP Rep. Adam Kinzinger, a US Air Force veteran who flew missions in Afghanistan, tweeted, “This is horrible – yet it’s the reality of announcing the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan. Removing the peacekeepers and leaving the Afghan people without support is a grave mistake, Mr. President.”

Meanwhile, the Taliban continues to make gains as local militias pop up to challenge it, propelling the country further and further into a state of civil war.

On Friday, Pentagon spokesperson John Kirby acknowledged the “deteriorating security situation” in Afghanistan, just one day after Biden gave a full-throated defense of the withdrawal.

The president announced the pullout in April, and last week said the US military mission in the country would be complete by the end of August. Biden has rejected the notion a Taliban takeover of the country is inevitable in the absence of US troops, expressing confidence in the Afghan military’s capacity to keep the insurgents at bay.

“We did not go to Afghanistan to nation-build. And it’s the right and the responsibility of the Afghan people alone to decide their future and how they want to run their country,” Biden said in an impassioned speech. “Nearly 20 years of experience has shown us that the current security situation only confirms that ‘just one more year’ of fighting in Afghanistan is not a solution but a recipe for being there indefinitely.”

2 thoughts on “George W. Bush: Biden’s Afghanistan withdrawal will be ‘unbelievably bad’ and it ‘breaks my heart’”
  1. @Afghanistan:Unfortunately, the US Government under Pres. Reagan pit too much weight on pressing the Soviets – at a time when this was totally unnecessary, thanks to beginning Gorbachov era. and when they were doing an extremely useful job: Fighting the Islamic State. That was what went out from Afghanistan poisoning the region far around, and the Soviets had felt its spread into some of their Federal States, especially Chechniya – but feared it most to spread to the big region of Khazan with its over 20 million Moslems. THAT’s why they went into Afghanistan and tried to stop the dangerous Jihad!
    And they nearly did so, for the benefit of the wide population – but especially the WOMEN: It was the first time, schools for girls, and for boys and girls were built, women received professional training and jobs, local regional elections were set up and held, a national government was set up – and in general: The rule of the radical Mullahs was crushed! A way to Freedom – for the first time in history!
    But, unfortunately, US politicks did not want to see of all this but only ‘a chance to harm the Soviets’ – bot a hint of care about the harm this would mean for millions of Afghans – and others far around. The same as, later, in Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Somalia: US weapons flooded the land, and “instructors” and a proxy war of terror and inhumanity – praised by our “embedded” press and media as “liberation”, MAKING THE TINY TALIBAN A WORLD POWER (and Boko Haram and other Radical Islamists, too). And Osama bin Laden was part of this as a US PROXY! (That he had anything to do with the 9 September in USA, however, is not even likely – that was planned somewhere in Saudia and the West.)
    But: The US warfare succeeded, a Truce was signed, and US support flew away – and what followed is what we can expect to follow now: The “Peace-Signing” Afghan government was found hanged from lamp posts at Kabul airport.
    It has bee n a hallmark of US politicks to, nearly always, side with the wrong side, from South America to Asia, Africa – you name it: BLINDNESS FOR REALITY (BUT BIG WISHES FOR SOMEONE’S POCKETS) that is US politics and values.

  2. Why do we have such problems with Nation Building? Seriously? The Brits did a TERRIBLE job with the Middle East, Indochina, etc. Meanwhile, look at what we’ve done: Rebuilt ALL of Europe. Japan. South Korea. Just to name a few.

    NOW for the trick questions:
    1) How long were American troops in Germany after WWII?
    2) How long were they in Japan after WWII?
    3) How long were they in Korea?
    Hint: They’re still there. And we have NOTHING to apologize for in doing so.

    The Iraqis were begging my niece to stay. So were the Afghanis. They know why.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *